Advertisement
News

LOGICAL trial addresses conservative vs liberal oxygen use in ICU patients following cardiac arrest

Make CHEST Physician® a trusted source
Paul J. Young, PhD
Paul J. Young, PhD

Early hyperoxemia following cardiac arrest has been associated with increases in mortality and poor neurological outcomes, but previous trials of oxygen restriction showed mixed results for patients who were unresponsive after resuscitation from cardiac arrest. Recently published results from the LOGICAL trial found no difference between groups receiving conservative or liberal oxygen therapy.1

“Probably, the LOGICAL trial in this space will end up being the last word,” said Paul J. Young, PhD, one of the lead investigators. “It’s a pretty big cardiac arrest trial, and there’s pretty clearly no sign of benefit.”

Results from LOGICAL, a nested trial within the Mega-ROX trial, were published in The New England Journal of Medicine. This randomized controlled trial involved 1,840 patients from ICUs in Australia, New Zealand, and Ireland. The primary outcome was survival with favorable functional outcome at 180 days, measured using the Extended Glasgow Outcome Scale.

Dr. Young, an intensive care specialist at the Medical Research Institute of New Zealand and Wellington Hospital, said that studies during the past decade have signaled a possible association between high oxygen levels on arrival to the ICU and poor mortality outcomes. Dr. Young led the ICU-ROX trial, which randomized 1,000 patients to conservative or liberal oxygen therapy, with a primary outcome being the number of ventilator-free days from randomization until day 28.2

“Within that trial, there was a signal that if you had had a cardiac arrest and you were allocated to conservative oxygen, that you had better functional outcomes than if you were allocated to liberal oxygen,” he said.

In the LOGICAL trial, adults who were unconscious and needing mechanical ventilation after cardiac arrest were randomized to either conservative or liberal oxygen therapy, with the default lower limit of Spo2 set at 90%. The alarm for the upper limit of Spo2 was 95% for the conservative arm, and Fio2 was decreased to 0.21 if the Spo2 was above the lower limit. No measurements limited upper Spo2 in the liberal arm, but the minimum Fio2 allowed during mechanical ventilation was 0.3.

In the conservative-oxygen group, 313 of 819 patients (38.2%) had a favorable functional outcome at 180 days, while 353 of 890 patients (39.7%) in the liberal-oxygen group had a favorable functional outcome. No adverse events were reported in either group.

“There are some caveats to the interpretation and, like everything, there’s always some uncertainty about it. But I think the vast likelihood, or operative truth, now is that conservative and liberal oxygen therapy result in similar outcomes for patients who are in intensive care after a cardiac arrest,” Dr. Young said.


References

1. LOGICAL Investigators and the Australian and New Zealand Intensive Care Society Clinical Trials Group, Hodgson CL, Mackle D, et al. Conservative oxygen for unresponsive patients after cardiac arrest. N Engl J Med. 2026;395(6):571-581. doi:10.1056/NEJMoa2513814

2. Young P, Mackle D, Bellomo R, et al. Conservative oxygen therapy for mechanically ventilated adults with suspected hypoxic ischaemic encephalopathy. Intensive Care Med. 2020;46(12):2411-2422. doi:10.1007/s00134-020-06196-y